musiclink/docs/reviews/docs.md

Code Review: Docs & Design Artifacts

Scope

• README.md
• docs/
• WORKLOG.md

Findings

✅ Strengths

• Intent/approach/work docs align with the Matrix-native implementation.
• README provides clear Matrix config and health endpoint usage.

⚠️ Issues / Opportunities

1. Design doc still references Matterbridge migration

   • docs/design-matrix-native-routing.md includes Matterbridge migration steps and open questions that are now resolved.
   • Consider updating or archiving it to reflect the Matrix-only state.

2. README prereq Go version outdated

   • README says Go 1.22+, but go.mod requires 1.24.0.
   • Update README to match the module version.

3. WORKLOG is stale

   • WORKLOG.md references Matterbridge and old crash loops.
   • Consider updating or moving it to an archive.

Notes

• If keeping historical context, add a short “historical” note to older docs rather than removing them entirely.