musiclink/docs/reviews/docs.md

Code Review: Docs & Design Artifacts

Scope

• docs/
• README.md
• WORKLOG.md

Findings

✅ Strengths

• Matrix-native design/intent/approach/work docs are consistent and aligned with implementation.
• README includes Matrix-native configuration, health endpoint, and E2EE limitation.
• Work log captures recent operational issues and next steps.

⚠️ Issues / Opportunities

1. README still frames Matterbridge as core architecture

   • Architecture section says it is designed to work as a Matterbridge sidecar; Matrix-native mode is now an equal option.
   • Consider reframing to describe two supported modes to avoid confusion.

2. Worklog mentions Go 1.22.8

   • WORKLOG.md references Go 1.22.8; repo now uses Go 1.24.0.
   • Consider updating the worklog or adding a note about the bump.

3. No migration guide for Matrix-native

   • Docs include config, but no step-by-step migration/cutover guidance for Matterbridge deployments.
   • Consider adding a short “migration” section covering shadow mode validation and cutover.

Notes

• Design doc open questions are mostly resolved (SDK choice, state store). Might update the design doc to close them.