diff --git a/docs/worklogs/2026-01-02-agent-update-tests-and-bug-fix.md b/docs/worklogs/2026-01-02-agent-update-tests-and-bug-fix.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..ade8ff9 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/worklogs/2026-01-02-agent-update-tests-and-bug-fix.md @@ -0,0 +1,172 @@ +--- +title: "Agent File Update Tests and Section Ordering Bug Fix" +date: 2026-01-02 +keywords: [testing, bash, agent-context, bug-fix, state-machine, specify] +commits: 1 +compression_status: uncompressed +--- + +# Session Summary + +**Date:** 2026-01-02 +**Focus Area:** Add comprehensive tests for agent file update logic and fix discovered bug + +# Accomplishments + +- [x] Created test-agent-update.sh with 33 test cases +- [x] Discovered and fixed bug in update-agent-context.sh section ordering +- [x] Tests cover: basic functionality, missing sections, timestamps, idempotency, change limits, DB entries, placement, edge cases +- [x] Closed skills-hgm (Add tests for agent file update logic) +- [x] Previous session: Completed skills-x33 (branch name tests - 27 tests) + +# Key Decisions + +## Decision 1: Test extraction approach using awk instead of sed + +- **Context:** Need to extract functions from update-agent-context.sh for isolated testing +- **Options considered:** + 1. `sed -n '/^function()/,/^}$/p'` - Original approach + 2. `awk '/^function\(\)/,/^}$/ {print; if (/^}$/) exit}'` - More precise + 3. Source entire script with mocked dependencies +- **Rationale:** awk with explicit exit on closing brace is more reliable for multi-function scripts +- **Impact:** Clean function extraction without pulling in adjacent functions + +## Decision 2: Fix the bug rather than document as expected behavior + +- **Context:** Found that Recent Changes section was silently skipped when preceded by Active Technologies +- **Rationale:** This was clearly unintended behavior - the code was supposed to update both sections +- **Impact:** Agent context files now correctly receive change entries regardless of section ordering + +# Problems & Solutions + +| Problem | Solution | Learning | +|---------|----------|----------| +| eval/sed extraction didn't work correctly for update_existing_agent_file | Used awk with explicit exit on `^}$` pattern | awk is more precise for function boundary detection | +| Tests failing: change entries not added to existing Recent Changes | Traced through code, found `## Recent Changes` caught by generic "close tech section on any ##" logic | State machine section handlers must check specific headers before generic patterns | +| Idempotency test counting wrong pattern | Pattern "Python + Django" appeared in both tech and change sections | Use anchored regex `^- pattern$` for specific line matching | + +# Technical Details + +## Code Changes + +- Total files modified: 2 +- Key files changed: + - `.specify/scripts/bash/update-agent-context.sh` - Fixed section ordering in while loop + - `.specify/scripts/bash/tests/test-agent-update.sh` - New test file (33 tests) + +## The Bug + +The `update_existing_agent_file` function processes files line-by-line with a state machine. When in the Active Technologies section (`in_tech_section=true`), encountering any `##` header would: + +1. Add pending tech entries +2. Echo the header line +3. Set `in_tech_section=false` +4. **Continue to next iteration** ← Bug here! + +This meant `## Recent Changes` was echoed but the change entry addition code (which checks `if [[ "$line" == "## Recent Changes" ]]`) was never reached. + +**Fix:** Check for `## Recent Changes` BEFORE the generic "any ## closes tech section" logic: + +```bash +# Handle Recent Changes section FIRST (before generic ## handling) +if [[ "$line" == "## Recent Changes" ]]; then + # Close tech section if we were in it + if [[ $in_tech_section == true ]]; then + if [[ $tech_entries_added == false ]] && [[ ${#new_tech_entries[@]} -gt 0 ]]; then + printf '%s\n' "${new_tech_entries[@]}" >> "$temp_file" + tech_entries_added=true + fi + in_tech_section=false + fi + echo "$line" >> "$temp_file" + # Add new change entry right after the heading + if [[ -n "$new_change_entry" ]]; then + echo "$new_change_entry" >> "$temp_file" + fi + ... +fi +``` + +## Test Categories + +1. **Basic Functionality** (4 tests) - Tech/change entries added, existing content preserved +2. **Missing Sections** (6 tests) - Creates sections when absent +3. **Timestamp Updates** (2 tests) - Updates `**Last updated**:` dates +4. **Idempotency** (1 test) - No duplicates when re-running +5. **Change Entry Limits** (5 tests) - Max 2 existing changes kept +6. **Database Entries** (3 tests) - DB-only additions work +7. **Tech Entry Placement** (3 tests) - Entries at correct position +8. **Edge Cases** (5 tests) - Empty, NEEDS CLARIFICATION, EOF handling +9. **format_technology_stack** (4 tests) - Helper function unit tests + +## Commands Used + +```bash +# Run the tests +bash .specify/scripts/bash/tests/test-agent-update.sh + +# Debug function extraction +eval "$(awk '/^update_existing_agent_file\(\)/,/^}$/ {print; if (/^}$/) exit}' script.sh)" + +# Trace execution +bash -x -c '...' +``` + +# Process and Workflow + +## What Worked Well + +- Test-first debugging: Writing tests exposed the bug immediately +- Incremental tracing: Adding debug output to narrow down the issue +- Hypothesis testing: Created minimal test cases to verify the bug cause + +## What Was Challenging + +- Function extraction: eval/sed patterns are finicky with nested braces +- Understanding state machine flow: Had to trace through manually to find where `continue` was short-circuiting + +# Learning and Insights + +## Technical Insights + +- Bash state machines need careful ordering: specific cases before generic patterns +- `continue` in while loops can silently skip subsequent handlers +- Test fixtures with `setup_test_file()` using heredocs are clean for bash testing +- grep patterns for line counting need anchoring to avoid false positives + +## Process Insights + +- When tests fail unexpectedly, the code might be buggy (not just the tests) +- Adding debug output (`echo "DEBUG: ..." >&2`) is fast way to trace bash + +# Context for Future Work + +## Open Questions + +- Should we add more tests for create_new_agent_file function? +- Consider shellcheck/shfmt for the test files? + +## Next Steps + +- skills-s92: Add tests for deploy-skill.sh (continues testing theme) +- skills-7bu: Add atomic file operations (related to file update code) +- Rebuild home-manager to deploy updated script + +## Related Work + +- [2026-01-01-ops-review-phase-3-and-worklog-migration.md](2026-01-01-ops-review-phase-3-and-worklog-migration.md) - Previous session +- skills-x33: Branch name tests (27 tests, completed in prior session) + +# Raw Notes + +- The deployed worklog skill still uses .org format; repo has .md +- Network issue prevented bd sync (192.168.1.108:3000 unreachable) +- Total test count across both test files: 60 tests (27 branch + 33 agent) + +# Session Metrics + +- Commits made: 1 +- Files touched: 2 +- Lines added/removed: +536/-13 +- Tests added: 33 +- Tests passing: 33/33